Job News & Views

Search

Post Your Resume

 

Print

It's The Cover Letter, Okay?

Jun 5 2009

Chad Broadus

"A great resume will get you not-rejected, a great cover letter will get you hired."

At least that's what David Heinemeier of the company 37Signals thinks. After reviewing scads of candidates, he's come to the conclusion that the resume, if reasonably presentable, is reduced to a check list of skills and experience. But it's the cover letter that will set you apart. He writes:

When I'm saddled with 70 applications for a job, I have to make some rough cuts very quickly. I literally have to decimate the pool. With the resume only doing 20% of the job, the key is left with the cover letter.

This means that 'If you like my resume, give me a call' doesn't make the cut for a cover letter. I need more romance and originality than that to pick up the phone.

So there you go, folks. Real world insight from a real hiring manager faced with culling through candidates. The take away: All that advice about tailoring your cover letter to the company and job? Turns out it's really true. Heinemeier goes on to explain:

t also means that you really have to tailor your tone to the company. Pulling out your Business Serious voice and addressing 'Dear Hiring Manager' instantly kicks you down a few levels....

The gut reaction builds immediately. If the first paragraph is a strike, the second has to work that much harder. If there's no hook in the first three, it's highly unlikely that anything is going to come of it.

So what does a cover letter good enough to get past Heinemeier look like? It's Web designer Jason Zimdars' Web introduction. In it, it's clear he's done his research. As a result, it hits the right tone and covers all bases. What Zimdars has done might not work for everyone in finance, his clean professional approach to his online persona is something to think about. And, we should note, Heinemeier's attitude toward suits certainly isn't in the mainstream of finance, but it does point toward the importance of understanding a firm's culture before you go off to the interview.

Comments (5)

"This guy may be right...but there is simpler way. READ THE REQUIREMENTS CAREFULLY. Understand the tone and granularity of the job requirement."

View all comments

Related content

Bookmark

  • Blinklist.com
  • Reddit.com
  • Digg.com
  • Furl.com
  • Google.com
  • Del.icio.us
  • Yahoo.com
  • Netscape.com
  • Stumbleupon.com

Comments (5)

  • This guy may be right...but there is simpler way. READ THE REQUIREMENTS CAREFULLY. Understand the tone and granularity of the job requirement. 90% Chances are hiring manager has created the job requirements which will give you his perspective of an ideal candidate. Regardless of your qualifications, they have just one concern, WHAT YOU CAN BRING TO THE TABLE?  Update your cover letter with respect to what requirement or project specifies. Most of us are rushed to the interviews and thats when we come to know what the project is all about. So please DONT FORGET THANK YOU letters. This is where you can add icing of your experience according to what you have gathered from your interview. Hope this helps who are looking for the job.

    chaitanya 10 Jun 2009

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • chaitanya,

    I agree. Painstakingly tailoring one's resume, cover letter and interview presentation to align as closely as possible with the job requirements, is an approach eFinancialCareers News has long advocated.

    You further state that the so-called "thank you" letter should "add icing to your experience," drawing upon what you learned during the interview. That is an excellent point! I recall one astute headhunter (Alan Geller of A.G. Barrington) explaining how an effective follow-up letter is NOT purposed to "thank" the interviewer. Instead, it should aim to show the interviewer that the candidate was listening for the employer's business needs. In Geller's view, MOST of the words in a candidate's post-interview follow-up letter should be devoted to re-stating the most important strategic goals (as defined by the employer) that the person hired will have to accomplish .... and only then, briefly outlining why you are the best-qualified candidate to deliver on those goals. Saying "thank you" is an entirely incidental, and perfunctory, aspect of the follow-up communication. (I fully endorse Alan Geller's view on this.)

    --Jon Jacobs, eFinancialCareers News staff

    Jon Jacobs 10 Jun 2009

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I don't disagree with the comments regarding the cover letter.  However, with the sheer volume of resumes flowing in to most positions, I am not sure a cover letter even gets read any longer (if it goes to HR).  If you are working with a hiring manager on a 'networked' position, they will read it because they dont have 172 resumes & letters to look at before lunch.  I feel cover letters to HR may be a black hole.
    Additionally, with the volume of email and resume key word search software, that will also effect the impact of a letter.    I like to see short to the point letters, its all I have time for.

    Jim Vancini 11 Jun 2009

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I recommend cover letters.  A good cover letter can help give you a chance at an interview, particularly now when companies get 200 resumes of ex-investment bankers who are applying for the junior research associate job.
    chaitanya, with regards to your comment about READING THE REQUIREMENTS CAREFULLY, most candidates only apply for the jobs that they meet or exceed the requirements of the position.  It still takes time to create a cover letter & resume, as well as create an online profile at the company's recruitment software database.  You're not going to do it if you don't meet or exceed because there are hundreds of overqualified people applying to anything they can get.

    Joshua Norman 15 Jun 2009

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I'm responding to Jim Vancini's comment that "cover letters to HR may be a black hole."  In general, I feel HR itself is a black hole!

    jlherring 18 Jun 2009

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

Add your comment

* Mandatory

You have 1200 characters left

Enter the code shown here or sign in / register to skip this step. (What is this?)

Post comment

Jobs

Col3
Col4
Col5
Col6
bottom

Site Information

eFinancialCareers is a Dice Holdings, Inc. company. Dice Holdings, Inc. is a publicly traded company listed on the New York Stock Exchange (Ticker: DHX)