TRANCHED: Bankers are not to blame

It’s all over. The end of the once-great investment banking industry came last week. The two remaining giants, Goldman and Morgan Stanley, were forced to accept a change of status; and Merrill and Lehman respectively merged with rivals and went bust.

The speed with which the landscape has altered has been jaw dropping. Emerging from the rubble is a universal banking world. And even at these early stages, the foundations of the next meltdown seem to have been laid.

The cycle goes something like this: initially, the conservative deposit-taking bank sets out to serve its customer base with investment banking products; the profitability of this activity drives up profits; as the market recovers, the most profitable universal banks set a benchmark for returns in the industry; higher and higher levels of risk are adopted in the race to get to the top of the pile; the bubble bursts and assets are written down, at which point investment banking arms are either closed or hived off.

As anyone who’s read the papers or watched the likes of Panorama this week will know, bankers have few friends. Vilified by politicians, the press and the public., talk is all of reforming the City’s greedy ways, capping bonuses and generally reigning in the excess.

However, the City doesn’t act in a vacuum, it is the place where financial risk is crystallised, but that risk is derived from a wide diversity of sources. Joe Bloggs in the street who takes out a mortgage on a house is a financial speculator taking a leveraged position on the property market. That ability to leverage has been approved by politicians, to allow the population at large to enjoy the benefits of home ownership.

The use of taxpayers’ money to shore up these institutions attracts enormous criticism, but the reality is that the capitalist economies and the City/Wall Street are highly connected. This connection is opportunity and greed and is common to both the man in the street and City bankers.

Against this tumultuous backdrop, the search for a new career continues in earnest. I have all but given up on headhunters as they’re swamped with CVs. Instead, I’ve widened my network and a number of new leads have already begun to appear.

The main problem right now is timing. I need to find a long-term role, but I also need a stop gap opportunity in the short term. And I don’t want to sacrifice short-term stability for the long-term aim of reinvigorating my career. Friends have found themselves battling this same challenge and have even resorted to giving time for free to potential employers in order to get back into the business.

Reinvention requires sacrifice and imagination, and both are required of those of us on the outside looking in.

CDO Joe is a structured products specialist who lost his job 19 weeks ago.

Comments (9)
  1. “Joe Bloggs in the street who takes out a mortgage on a house is a financial speculator taking a leveraged position on the property market. That ability to leverage has been approved by politicians, to allow the population at large to enjoy the benefits of home ownership. ”

    Yes but Joe Bloggs in the street invariably doesn’t know what you mean by ‘leveraged position’ , he is merely responding to the overwhelming persuasion engineered in The City that debt of this size is now ok and can be managed by magic.. In addition to that most people are not financial speculators, they merely want to own a home.

    To blame Joe Bloggs in the street is cheap my friend. This has not been a bottom up drive it has been frantically driven from the top in The City, who have cajoled, threatened and influenced politicians and dazzled the public with what they said is possible. Most people take on mortgages in good faith as they want a home. You did this for a living, every day of your life, you knew what you were doing, the public merely followed the lead given to them and know will be the ones to suffer.

    If you want to see who is to blame for this mess, look in the mirror

  2. Joe Bloggs has been offered 120% mortgage that he cannot pay back. He doesn’t care much about CDOs Swaps and leveraging.
    If you lend money to people who cannot pay it back, it is your problem. Especially if you know that they are unlikely to pay it back (otherwise you wouldn’t classify them in advance as ‘sub prime’).

  3. I hope we have a financial meltdown…it will bring the ‘Masters of the Universe’ back down to earth and hopefully stop the outrageous spending that is normally attributed to wealthy Arabs, Russians and assorted Financiers.

    This whole ‘who is the wealthiest’ thing is so crude and diverts attention from key issues afflicting the human race!

  4. Jon P… stop it, please! You are beyond pathetic. Pure jealousy.

  5. The blame should be split 60:40. Banks should never have been so foolish as to lend money to fools who patently couldn’t pay it back. Individuals should never have been so foolish as to borrow money from fools who would patently be in big trouble when they inevitably defaulted. Times were good. There was no guarantee they would last.

  6. fxo man…i can assure you it is not jealousy – far from it!

    it is more a case of disappointment and disgust at how supposedly intelligent people are driven by such greed and selfishness! The majority of course reject such allegations and always seem to have the answers (as i am sure you do) however, it is the inescapable truth that humankind seems hell bent on repeatedably lauding the achievements of the wrong people – people that are value destroyers rather than those who are genuinely trying to improve the human condition.

    I strongly suspect that you are someone caught up in your little bubble, believeing that all you do is noble and worthwhile when in fact it is utterly pointless.

  7. Roger – spot on.
    and there were plenty of people who were in it for the money and a property market that could never go down

  8. Greed has no base. Even the most intelligent ones give in as we all have evidently seen in the recent financial turmoil. Why blame the poor chap who wanted a safe home for his kids?

  9. Get a real job – not conjuring up paper wealth by repackaging monetary expansion into securities that analysts price according to “models” that only seem to work when there is a bidder around. Do something real like produce something, learn to fix things or provide services that people really need (not what someone told them they need)

React

You can react by using a display name and your personal information will not be displayed.

Tell us your news

Email the editor with your feedback, news, tips or topics.