Are day traders all trash?

They’ve “pissed off” ANZ boss Mike Smith, and chances are they’ll be top of your hate-list too. Are blood-sucking day traders the trailer-park trash of the finance world?

Never one to mince his words, Smith said last week that ANZ’s share price should never have collapsed over Opes Prime and that its descent was all down to “a bunch of sophisticated day traders”, who were Opes’ clients.

“The position is very unpleasant and I have to say I’m somewhat pissed off about the whole thing,” he added.

Who are these sophisticated (or not) day traders? According to the stereotype, you’ll find the scumbags stuck to their screen, desperately seeking to ride the wave of market momentum, taking ludicrous risks, and being generally politically incorrect every inch of the way.

In the US, the SEC reckons this is all “extremely risky and can result in substantial financial losses in a very short period of time”.

Is it time now for us Aussies to get tough on these traitorous traders? Is Mike Smith right to be irate? Or are day traders as good as the next bloke? Let us know below.

Comments (10)
  1. is he seriously taking the moral high ground against day-traders??!! …pot…kettle…black….

  2. Day trading is still trading. If you can be one step ahead of the market then good on you! Not every day trader takes ludicrous risks.

  3. Traders are low. Day traders are even lower. Want a guy with minimal education, little understanding of long term investment principles and an ego the size of Mount Everest, try your average day trading dude. Trust me on this.

  4. I am a day trader. I do not suck blood, I do not live in a trailer. I am not aware of being a scumbag. I am aware of the level of risk to which I am exposed in each transaction. In what way I am considered to be politically incorrect remains a mystery. For anybody in the financial sector to suggest that buying and selling currencies in the hope of making a profit is immoral has me scratching my chin.

  5. Day traders like to make money. My apologies.

  6. And…errr…how much did you pay for ANZ?

  7. The comments of ANZ’s boss is simply passing a responsibility to somebody else. Well, he is the big boss and is accountable and responsible to what happened. He can blame others, but day traders are just needed people within organizations, with defined job descriptions, and you can not blame people for taking certain jobs with certain responsibilities. Why did ANZ’s boss give them such responsibilities? Or he was just negligent, so he did not know?

  8. Kudos to all profitable day-traders – especially those trading with their own money.

  9. Day trading is not easy money ask any day trader.

  10. Most of the traders within the global banks paticularly traders of derivatives and CDS are all dodgy traders. Investment banks obviously tolerate teher dodgy tradings to make profit. But this is what you call glamorised corruption in the banking sector. Most of the time thier front office traders are in conivance with thier operation to conceal fraudulenta dn risk trades. Like Societe Generale not just its desk in Europe but across its world front office desk. Australia included. This has been happening in the past 3 years.

React

You can react by using a display name and your personal information will not be displayed.

Tell us your news

Email the editor with your feedback, news, tips or topics.